The whole thing was entirely made up.
Paying It Forward
The tale starts back in 2017, when D'Amico and his then-girlfriend, Katelyn McClure, posted a GoFundMe campaign called "Paying It Forward."
The former couple was hoping to raise $10,000 for Johnny Bobbitt Jr., a homeless veteran who allegedly used his last $20 to help McClure buy enough gas to get home.
The campaign soon took off, with the couple raking in a cool $402,706 for the alleged roadside hero. The pair even made national TV appearances once the story went viral.
But there was one big problem: McClure was never stranded. The three had cooked up the bizarre Internet scheme together, and years later, it looks like their legal troubles are far from over.
The fraud started to unravel in 2018, when it was discovered that the couple had only shared $75,000 of the earnings with Bobbitt.
Which, you know, doesn't exactly scream "paying it forward."
D'Amico and McClure's shared home was raided by police, and the couple turned themselves in soon after.
According to Gizmodo, all three of the swindlers have since pleaded guilty. Bobbitt, sentenced back in 2019, got five years of probation. McClure is due for her own sentencing in September, and faces potential jail time as well.
Fortunately, GoFundMe also issued refunds to anyone who donated.
READ MORE: GoFundMe Fraudster Sentenced to Five Years in Prison for Homeless Man Scam [Gizmodo]
More on Internet scams: FBI Offers Huge Reward for "Cryptoqueen" Accused of Stealing $4 Billion