A Finnish AI startup called Vainu has spent the last three months relying on prison labor to train its AI algorithm.
Vainu previously paid people through Mechanical Turk, a service where people perform menial tasks — like those necessary for preparing AI’s training data — just like many other startups. But Vainu found that it got more bang for its buck enlisting the Finnish Criminal Sanctions Agency (CSA), which had access to more Finnish-speaking labor than the largely English-speaking Mechanical Turk, according to The Verge.
And though Vainu and the CSA are working hard to spin the news as a positive development for the prisoners, Vainu’s practices seem to herald in a new era where prison labor continues to provide cheap, unrewarding labor, even if the specific jobs involve new technology.
Vainu uses human labor to scan news articles and determine whether or not they discuss business acquisitions or similar topics. That way, the company can use those articles to train an AI algorithm that Vainu hopes will help connect companies with contractors, according to The Verge. But there was only one person on Mechanical Turk that helped Vainu scan articles written in Finnish.
“We saw that and said, ‘okay, this is not going to be enough,'” Vainu co-founder Tuomas Rasila told The Verge. He went on to describe how he had a eureka moment upon realizing his office was in the same building as the CSA. He told The Verge that he suddenly realized, “Hey, we could actually use prison labor.”
Vainu pays the CSA, which divvies a portion of the cash among working prisoners, roughly the same amount it would for the same labor on Mechanical Turk. But that means that the actual workers make less money through this arrangement than on Mechanical Turk, which The Atlantic reports tends to pay out just a few dollars per hour.
The CSA claims that by working with an AI startup, the prisoners are building up job skills that are relevant in a society facing ever-increasing workplace automation. But there’s no indication that performing these routine tasks will actually help inmates land an AI job once they’re release from prison.
“The hook is that we have this kind of hype circulating around AI so that we can masquerade really old forms of labor exploitation as ‘reforming prisons,'” UC San Diego communications professor Lilly Irani told The Verge. “They’re connecting social movements, reducing it to hype, and using that to sell AI.”
READ MORE: Inmates in Finland are training AI as part of prison labor [The Verge]
More on prisons: U.S. Prisons Are Covertly Gathering Inmates’ Biometric Voice Data