neoscope-logo
28 May 2020
FITTER. BETTER. HAPPIER.
Scientific Animations/Victor Tangermann

Scientists Retract Study Claiming Vapes Cause Heart Attacks

Did this academic journal give in to "pressure from e-cig interests?"
by Victor Tangermann / February 20 2020

In an official statement, the editors of the Journal of the American Heart Association (JAHA) explained why they retracted a study claiming that e-cigarettes increase the likelihood of having a heart attack.

The now-retracted study by two University of California at San Francisco researchers, published in JAHA last year, claimed they had found an “association between e‐cigarette use and having had a myocardial infarction.” They concluded that the “effect of e‐cigarettes are similar as conventional cigarette and dual use of e‐cigarettes and conventional cigarettes at the same time is risker [sic] than using either product alone.”

The study received loads of mainstream coverage, from CNN to USA Today, as Vice points out.

But tobacco control expert Brad Rodu, from the University of Louisville, discovered that the study had a major fault: Many of those analyzed for the study were also current or former smokers, as Vice reports.

That reality likely skewed their findings, according to Rodu — an argument later backed up by several senior researchers in an open letter, in which they argued that a conclusion that’s “not supported by underlying data” could “mislead practitioners and policymakers.”

“A retraction is not a trivial matter,” Rodu told Vice. “It’s a significant action. Saying it was a mistake is too weak.”

On Twitter, though, paper author Stanton Glanz shot back, claiming that JAHA had given in to “pressure from e-cig interests.”

Keep up. Subscribe to our daily newsletter.

I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its User Agreement and Privacy Policy
////////////