--- title: "Uber Criticized for Charging Surge Pricing for Riders Escaping Mass Shooting" description: "At least 16 were injuried in a subway shooting in Brooklyn, NYC. Public transit disruption meant Uber turned on surges, charing 10x as much for rides." date: "2022-04-13" modified: "2022-04-13" authors: - name: "Lonnie Lee Hood" link: "https://futurism.com/authors/ahood" url: "https://futurism.com/the-byte/uber-surge-shooting-nyc" categories: - "Future Society" tags: - "nypd" - "shooting" - "the digest" - "Uber" --- # Uber Criticized for Charging Surge Pricing for Riders Escaping Mass Shooting ![At least 16 were injuried in a subway shooting in Brooklyn, NYC. Public transit disruption meant Uber turned on surges, charing 10x as much for rides.]() *\Image: David Dee Delgado/Getty Images\* ## Safety First Fear not, citizens. In a mass shooting event, [Uber is there]() to carry you to safety — for the low cost of surge pricing, of course. We wish that had come from a dystopian novel, but that's exactly what happened before Uber finally shut off surge pricing after the horrific NYC subway shooting yesterday, in which [10 people were shot and 23 were injured](), causing major transit disruption. Because of the traffic increase as people tried to get out of the area, [*Newsweek* reports](), Uber was charging nearly 10 times as much near the scene of the crime. "People are scared, let them get out safely," [one user said online](), posting a photo of a nearly $70 Uber ride. "Our hearts go out to the victims of this morning's terrible shooting in Sunset Park," an Uber spokesperson told *Newsweek**.* "Following the incident, Uber disabled surge pricing in the vicinity and capped pricing citywide." It's not clear precisely how long surge charges were turned on, but we do know it lasted several hours. The shooting happened around 8:30 am ET and that [*Bloomberg* reported the app]() had decided to disable the feature just before 1 pm ET. And while it's better than nothing that Uber is reversing charges during the period before it did show, that won't mean much to people who were dissuaded from escaping the crisis by the sky-high fees. ## In-cop-etence Uber's algorithm doesn't predict shootings, of course, although [it's absolutely true they could've moved faster]() to shut off surges or relied more efficiently on the "Global Security Center" [they say]() "monitors and flags issues that may affect our business and the communities in which we operate — 24 hours a day, seven days a week." Uber alone shouldn't have to bear the weight of emergency transit issues amid violence though, especially not in a city that claims to [remember 9/11 so well](). Just throwing this out there, but maybe the NYC police department — [which former Mayor Mike Bloomberg]() bragged was the world's seventh largest army and is [today's 24th largest global military spender]() — could take [some of those billions]() and use it for citywide emergency transit planning instead? Since there were around 3,500 officers on duty in the area yesterday, [according to one lawyer](), and it still took them nearly[ 24 hours to catch the guy,]() surely [budget isn't the problem]()? **More on police kerfuffles:** [*Gun Shot Detection Cameras Alerting Cops to Slamming Doors Instead*]()