X-ray imaging of the Perseus galaxy cluster with Chandra data closer to the center and XMM-Newton data on the outskirts. Image Credit: Chandra/XMM-Newton/ESA

There’s been a few articles in the popular press recently announcing the discovery of dark matter particles coming from the Sun. This is not the case. No science team is claiming they’ve discovered dark matter. The story traces it origin to a paper being published in MNRAS, which could be an indirect detection of dark matter, but could also be a few other things. It is an interesting paper, nonetheless.

What the paper actually looks at is possible evidence of axions coming from the Sun. Axions are hypothetical particles that were first proposed in 1977 to address certain issues in quantum chromodynamics (QCD), which describes the behavior of quarks and such that make up protons and electrons (among other things). There has been no evidence for axions, but if they exist, then the Sun should produce axions through nuclear interactions similar to the way it produces neutrinos.

According to the model, axions would be be low mass, chargeless particles that don’t interact strongly with light. This would make them a suitable candidate for cold dark matter. Of course this would also make them particularly difficult to observe directly. But unlike other dark matter candidates, axions do interact slightly with light and electromagnetic fields. So we might be able to see them by their interaction with Earth’s magnetic field.

In the paper the authors demonstrate that high energy axions striking the Earth’s magnetic field could produce x-rays. When they modeled this idea they found that axion-induced x-rays would have a seasonal variation due to the varying tilt of Earth’s axis (and thus its magnetic field). They then looked at x-ray data from the XMM-Newton spacecraft, and found that it had in fact detected a seasonal variation of x-rays. This variation is consistent with the axion model.

Of course before we can say that it’s definitely axions, we need to look for other possible explanations. Not surprisingly there are several. For example, the seasonal variations could be due to subtle and complex interactions between the solar wind and Earth’s magnetic field. So axions are a good candidate for this cyclic variation, but not the only candidate.

Where things could get interesting is through a more detailed study of the seasonal x-ray variations. If they are produced by axions, then the x-rays should have distinct signatures in their spectrum that would distinguish them from other models. So like many cutting edge discoveries it has potential without clear confirmation.

Paper: G. W. Fraser, et al. Potential solar axion signatures in X-ray observations with the XMM-Newton observatory. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 20 October, 2014

*Christian Beck, who has worked on axions at Queen Mary, University of London, also weighed in: “Dark matter axions, or axion-like particles, could be responsible for this as they can convert to photons in the magnetic field of the Earth. The discovery could potentially be very important. What’s less clear, however, is whether any other explanation of the measured effect can be excluded. A true discovery of dark matter that is convincing for most scientists would require consistent results from several different experiments using different detection methods, in addition to what has been observed by the Leicester group." (emphasis added)

This article was written by Brian Koberlein and originally published at One Universe at a Time. Read our original coverage of this story here.


Share This Article